Tags

, , , , , , , ,

After I’d learned my big Buddhist lesson as a youth in Thailand and Laos, I began to devour all the Buddhist books I could – which, in Bangkok, was quite a few. One of these was Thich Nhat Hanh‘s Peace Is Every Step, which pointed to the kinds of harms from anger that my upcoming book explores.

Nhat Hanh’s approach to anger in the book was one that I would now call nondual, and I already appreciated that: recognize your anger and step back from it, in a way that seemed to be working. But then I added a critique:

TNH recognizes and deals with anger in a way appropriate to a Vietnamese monk. “Breathing in, I know that I am angry. Then I say, ‘Hello, anger. How are you today?’ and I calm it to sleep like a mother.”
Me, I become mindful in the manner of a jaded, cynical, ironic Gen Xer. I make fun of my anger. I make it ironic. And I poke a little fun at New Age positivity in the process. Something like: “Hm, I’m angry, but I should be happy! But – I like being angry! I want to be pissed off, dammit! Growl, snarl, nobody fuck with me!” Said in a properly ironic tone of mind, by the time I’ve finished this I’ve already got the same kind of cynical grin on my face that accompanies a description of UN bureaucrats.
After all, when I’m pissed off, nothing cheers me up more than making a nasty, barbed wisecrack – even, it seems, if the target is myself.

I entitled that journal entry “Anger, you buttwipe!” And I am still fond of it; it does a great job of capturing the sort of person I was at age 21. Thirty years later, though, I no longer agree with it – though I wish I could. I still really like the idea of dealing with my anger by ironically and cynically mocking it. But there’s just one sad problem with that approach: it doesn’t work.

The recognition that came quickly to me in Thailand was that most if not all of our suffering comes from harmful emotions. What took me much longer to realize was just how hard it is to fix those – and it took even longer to figure out techniques that would work at fixing them.

In that particular regard, it didn’t help that the Buddhist thinker I would next come to learn from, the one I would soon immerse myself in most deeply, was the great Indian philosopher Śāntideva. Śāntideva’s critique of anger is even stronger than Thich Nhat Hanh’s – but in a way that, I think, is often counterproductive to its own goals. He wants to fight fire with fire: one is at war with harmful emotions (kleśas) like anger. And so he declares: “Let my choice be anger toward anger.” (BCA VI.41)

The problem with Śāntideva’s approach – or my own youthful one – is that this is just not how anger and other harmful emotions work. It turns out that we do not have the kind of precision that an anger-at-anger approach requires. My book notes that this is a problem with philosopher Myisha Cherry‘s supposedly positive “Lordean rage”. According to Cherry, “Lordean” rage is a kind of anger that supposedly has different aims and targets than other kinds of anger – but there is no psychological way to separate this kind of rage from any other kind. A poignant example is Martin Luther King Jr., famous for his anger at injustice – yet King himself criticized that anger because he recognized how hard that anger is to control, as evidenced on the day he died when he shoved his girlfriend across a hotel room.

Adobe Stock illustration copyright by213.

The key breakthrough I came to notice in myself is that emotions, and anger especially, continue irrespective of their content and target. When George W. Bush was no longer president, my longstanding and smoldering rage at him abated relatively quickly – yet almost immediately, without my noticing the fact at first, my anger quickly found other targets, from the censoriousness of the Catholic League to the prevalence of car alarms. At work in the following years, I noticed days where I felt a little angry at a boss and it segued into unrelated anger at the Social Justice movement. I think this pattern is pretty familiar to most of us: it’s all too easy to snap at someone around us for something minor because you’re mad about something else. This is why it doesn’t work to choose anger toward anger (or anger at unjust targets, for that matter). Anger just isn’t that selective. The same with the kind of milder irritation expressed in “Anger, you buttwipe!”: the irritation, too, is just going to stick around once permitted.

So then what do you do about anger? All of this is the genius behind the East Asian and Tibetan nondual approach to mindfulness, which underlies Thich Nhat Hanh’s approach but is also found in modern mindfulness techniques like Headspace and Goenka. Tara Brach in Radical Acceptance makes a direct critique of my old brand of name-calling that turns into a contructive solution:

Like inquiry, noting is an opportunity to communicate unconditional friendliness to our inner life. If fear arises and we pounce on it with a name, “Fear! Gotcha!” we’re only creating more tension. Naming an experience is not an attempt to nail an unpleasant experience or make it go away. Rather, it is a soft and gentle way of saying, “I see you, Mara.” This attitude of Radical Acceptance makes it safe for the frightened and vulnerable parts of our being to let themselves be known. (79-80)

Key to this approach, and contrary to Śāntideva, is that you don’t judge your emotions as they arise. They may well be bad – anger usually is – but your negative judgement of them only feeds them. If you’re annoyed at the bad thought, that makes more annoyance. If you react negatively to fear, you’ll get more fear, fear of the bad thought that will turn right back around into regular fear. Thus Headspace’s series of meditations on restlessness subtly acknowledge that restlessness of thought is a problem, asking you to make small lifestyle alterations to make restless thoughts less prevalent overall – but in the moment, while you are meditating, you don’t try to stop the restlessness, just to notice it. For Brook Ziporyn’s description of Tiantai Buddhism gets it exactly right: “It is by trying to eliminate our desires, whether by suppressing them or satisfying them, that we perpetuate them!”